Home prices over time

From the All the Numbers wiki · Housing

Nobody knows what a home will be worth in ten years. The plan still needs a number, because the home's value sets what a sale brings in, what property tax costs, and how much a home equity line can borrow.

The rule

The default assumption is 3.5% a year, nominal.[1] It is built from PWL Capital's expectations for a personal residence: a 1% a year return above inflation, plus its 2.5% inflation expectation[2] (see inflation and today's dollars). PWL states the residence return in real terms; the two are added, not compounded, which gives 3.5% rather than 3.525%.

Until 26 September 2026 the default was 2%, the Bank of Canada's inflation target, which means no real growth.

The figure is for the typical home over decades. A single home is far more variable: PWL puts the yearly volatility of an individual Canadian home at 14.7%, of which 4.2 points come from the market and 10.5 from the particular property.[3]

Prices can fall

One steady rate is a simplification. Real home prices move unevenly and can fall for years at a time. A PWL Capital study of apartments in twelve Canadian cities from 2005 to 2024 found prices in Calgary fell on average over the five years 2015 to 2019, and prices in Toronto and Hamilton declined after 2022. Over the whole period, a renter who invested the difference ended with more than an owner in seven of the twelve cities, and the two came out about even on average.[4] The study also notes that owning means putting a large share of your money into one home, whose price can swing as much as a stock's. On the house page, the "If the home grows less or more" table shows how much your own answer depends on the rate.

A new home's starting price

A home added to a plan starts at $600,000 until you enter its price.[5] It is a round figure a little under the national average resale price that CREA reported for September 2026, $666,538. It is a place to start, not a price for your city: the first page you see after adding a home asks for the real one. The down payment starts at 20% of the price, the least that needs no mortgage insurance,[6] so the first mortgage the plan shows carries no premium. A figure left at its starting value is listed among what the plan assumes about the home.

What the engine does

  • Starts a home at its purchase price and grows it at the rate set for that home, compounding smoothly through the year.
  • Uses that value for a sale, for property tax, which grows with the home's value (see what a house costs to hold), and as the limit on borrowing against the home in a short plan.
  • Lets the rate be changed for each home.
  • In the Simulation view, draws a different growth rate for each year around the assumption, using the volatility above, with each home drawn independently of the markets. See Monte Carlo.

What it deliberately does not

  • Treat the figure as a forecast or an appraisal. It is labelled as an assumption wherever it is used.
  • Differ by city, neighbourhood or type of home.
  • Follow a market cycle. Outside the Simulation view, value grows at a steady rate.
  • Link home values to the investment markets; no correlation is available to use.
  • Tie rent to home prices. Rent has its own growth rate; see rent.

See also

  • A home you already own · A home you own when the plan starts is entered as it stands today — what it is worth, what is left on the mortgage, the rate and payment, when the term ends — and runs from the plan's first month, with no purchase.
  • Inflation and today's dollars · The default inflation rate is 2.5% a year. A future dollar amount can be shown as is, or divided by (1 + inflation) for each year to show what it would buy today.
  • Monte Carlo: many market histories · The Simulation page runs the plan 500 times with investment returns and home prices drawn at random each year, then shows the spread of net worth and how many runs finish, borrow or run out of money.
  • Net worth, as the plan counts it · Net worth is everything the plan holds (cash, investment and registered accounts, homes at market value) minus mortgages, credit lines, debts and tax owing. It is not reduced for selling costs or for tax on money still in an RRSP.
  • Rent, and when it stops · Rent is its own line in the plan rather than part of living expenses, and it stops the month your first home closes — because a household that has bought is not paying both. Give it an end date if you would keep renting past that.
  • Renting out part of your home · Suite income is taxable and its expenses are deductible on the rented portion, but renting can also limit the principal-residence exemption on the eventual sale. All the Numbers taxes the gain on the rented share when the home is sold, unless you tick that the rental needed no structural change and you claim no capital cost allowance; then the whole gain stays exempt.
  • Renting versus buying · All the Numbers compares a plan that buys a home with the same plan that never buys, and the money the home would have taken stays in your accounts and is saved like any other leftover cash. It shows when owning pulls ahead on net worth, if it does. It is a comparison under assumptions, not a verdict.
  • Selling a home · A sale turns the home's projected market value into cash after selling costs (your province's typical commission, the sales tax on it and legal fees) and the mortgage payout. The gain on a principal residence is exempt from tax, apart from the part that was rented out when the exemption does not cover it.
  • What a house costs to hold · Property tax, maintenance, insurance and utilities are estimated as rates against the home's value, with sourced defaults. Property tax then grows with inflation, maintenance and insurance with the home's value, and utilities with inflation.
  • When the plan runs short of cash · When a month needs more money than the plan has, it draws savings in a set order, then borrows on a home equity line at 5.13% and an unsecured line at 8.38%, as far as a lender would lend. When no lender would lend more, the projection stops.
  • Which assumption matters most · The sensitivity chart moves one assumption at a time, down and up by a fixed step, and ranks them by how much the final net worth in today's dollars changes. Inflation is often the largest bar because it moves much more than one number.

References

  1. ↑PWL Capital — Financial Planning Assumptions (Market Capitalization Weighted Portfolio), mid-year 2026 data update, §3 · Default nominal home-price appreciation a year: PWL's expected real capital return on a personal residence plus its expected inflation. A labelled, editable assumption, not a forecast. · 3.5% · effective 2026-08-17
  2. ↑PWL Capital — Financial Planning Assumptions (Market Capitalization Weighted Portfolio), mid-year 2026 data update, Table 1 (Expected Inflation Composition) · Assumed long-run CPI inflation: half Canadian historical inflation since 1900, half the Bank of Canada target (PWL Capital, Financial Planning Assumptions, Table 1) · 2.5% · effective 2026-08-17
  3. ↑PWL Capital — Financial Planning Assumptions (Market Capitalization Weighted Portfolio), mid-year 2026 data update, §3 Primary Residence, Table 2 · Yearly volatility of an individual Canadian home's value: market plus idiosyncratic (PWL Capital, Financial Planning Assumptions, §3 and Table 2) · 14.7% · effective 2026-08-17
  4. ↑Felix, B. and Bin Arif, H., "Renting vs. Owning a Home in Canada 2005 – 2024", PWL Capital white paper, September 2025 · PWL Capital study of twelve Canadian metropolitan areas, January 2005 to December 2024: apartment prices fell for years at a time in some (Calgary had a negative 5-year annualized return over 2015 to 2019; Toronto and Hamilton prices declined after 2022); a renter investing the difference ended with more than an owner in seven of the twelve areas, a geometric average renter-to-owner wealth ratio of 0.99 · effective 2025-09-04
  5. ↑CREA — national statistics news release, 16 October 2026: national average home price $666,538 in September 2026 (not seasonally adjusted), down 1.6% from a year earlier · A home added to a plan takes this price until one is entered: a round figure a little under the national average resale price · $600,000 · effective 2026-10-25
  6. ↑FCAC: down payments (mortgage insurance is required on a down payment under 20% of the price) · A home added to a plan has a down payment of the share of the price below which mortgage insurance is required, until one is entered, so the default mortgage carries no premium · effective 2026-10-25
  7. FCAC: down payments · Default insurance required below this down-payment fraction · 20% · effective 2016-02-15